I'll start with the positives. The lot is beautiful! Huge, mature trees and water on two sides make it an amazing and large lot.n They did an amazing job with the beach and rock surrounding it. The A/C worked well. There is a lot of space, including a separate living area.
As for the negatives, unfortunately, there were quite a few. This is an older house, likely built in the 80's that has clearly been added onto in order to accommodate more guests. The result is a pretty funky layout with a central hallway (that clearly used to be an exterior wall) dividing the property into half.
It seems like it is in mid-update as there were wires hanging out where lights should be, there is a lot of siding that doesn't match, windows were cracked, lights don't work, incomplete drywall work, etc.
We had issues with a number of things including them not having the soap and shampoo they said on the posting, the internet went out after 2 nights, the umbrellas pictured on the beach over the hammock chairs weren't present, the gas grill didn't work, the boat launch they said we could use wouldn't let us use it, etc. The owners, to their credit, were responsive when we had stuff come up, it was just frustrating to have that many things go wrong.
Generally, I think it's a great option, it was just a question of value; for the rates they charge, I don't expect to have that many issues with amenities, I don't expect to see hair in the shower drains, unfinished dry wall in the master shower, holes in the ceiling, etc. It's just not that nice.