My husband and three young adult children stayed here for three nights and really had a good, affordable experience! It was great to have three bedrooms and the beds, aside from the plastic sheets on them, were the comfiest I've had in years! It was nicely decorated too. We were 20 minutes or less from everywhere we wanted to go. And I highly recommend the El Greco restaurant, which is about 4 minutes away.
We had some issues but got a really good response from the host. For example when I let him know there was no coffee maker, the next morning he brought a brand-new coffee maker, filters, creamer, sugar and coffee!! And when we had Internet issues our first time, he took care of that as well. My only issues were that two of the outlets were loose and we could not plug things in (in one bedroom and the living room), there were only two box fans instead of one for each bedroom (but that couldn't have been plugged in anyway). Some other issues were not under the control of the host like squeaky floorboards, loud people on the second floor -- but we have DEFINITELY run across these things in most rentals we have stayed at and is not a big deal. I think some people are way too picky.