Ratings based on 114 Guest Reviews

Hear it directly from our travellers
5.0 out of 5
100% of guests recommend
4.9 Room cleanliness
TRAVELOCITY GUEST REVIEWS
Hear it directly from our travellers
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Beautiful waterfront rental

Posted Nov. 25, 2024 on HomeAway
The property was beautiful and the hosts very friendly. The central location on the island made it very easy to explore by car but also had easy access by walking to both the Caribbean and Atlantic beaches. Highly recommended
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Our Future Home Island

Posted Jun. 29, 2024 on HomeAway
Sorry for the babbling, but I can't put into words what the experience we had with the house, island, people and most of all the hosts (Debbie and Phillip) of this property. It is our 25th Anniversary and we have spent years going to many all inclusive resorts around the Carribean. Baywatch cottage by far is the most beautiful place we have ever been to. The views are breathtaking, but seeing the wildlife swim by you on the dock was an experience that will be hard to beat. Exploring the island during the day and being shown the exquisite sites by our new lifelong friends Debbie and Philip was an amazing adventure. The beaches are like no other. At night we spent the time watching the fish, sharks, turtles and stingrays swim by. We are sorry it took us so long to find a place like this. It is out of a movie. It is not a question of if we will be back because we already want to book a trip this fall. It sounds too good to be true, we know, but when you go be prepared to want to put roots down on LI. Out of 5 stars... this place is a 10!
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Very Nice

Posted Jun. 17, 2024 on HomeAway
This is a private cottage on the bay its very comfortable. We enjoyed our stay and would come back again.
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Beautiful

Posted Jun. 15, 2024 on HomeAway
Everything you expect
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Paradise

Posted Jun. 15, 2024 on HomeAway
Second time back and couldn’t be happier. Small slice of heaven
5 out of 5
by A traveller

A beautiful hidden gem

Posted May 25, 2024 on HomeAway
The location is absolutely beautiful. Enough seclusion to enjoy the stay but very close proximity to grocery and a few restaurants. The property owner is wonderful and very helpful/easy to communicate with. 5 stars all around!
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Baywatch Cottage Retirement stay

Posted May 15, 2024 on HomeAway
Debbie and Phil were very kind and responsive. The cottage was clean and had everything we needed. We highly recommend staying there. It was so quiet and peaceful! Just what we needed after our retirement and move to a new state.
5 out of 5
by A traveller

Stunning place, best hosts

Posted Apr. 7, 2024 on HomeAway
Loved every minute, thanks Debbie and Philip!
5 out of 5
by A traveller

The quiet life

Posted Apr. 6, 2024 on HomeAway
Lovely quiet location. We were looking for something that was off the beaten path and we found exactly what we were looking for. We travelled the island from one end to the other twice with stops in between to walk the wonderful beaches. Back at the cottage we found everything we needed to make ourselves at home. Hats off to the owners.
5 out of 5
by A traveller from Salem, MA, USA

Beautiful and clean cottage

Posted Mar. 17, 2024 on HomeAway
Just a lovely experience during our stay. The host was wonderful and had many tips for us during our Long Island experience. This property in person is so impressive. Very well maintained and stocked. Will be booking with this host again in the future!