I recommend Casa Pelayo. The staff were amazing; I cannot say enough good things about them! The rental apartment was clean, bed comfy and had good A/C. It had all the necessities - I would not call it a super luxury place, but it was a good value for the price. It’s a little quirky because you check in at one office, but then walk one block over to get to the units. (There is parking nearby so you can unload luggage right by the unit.) It’s about a 20 min walk from Old San Juan. There is a fenced parking area, which is nice. It is rocky and we got a flat tire, but the staff bent over backwards to help us, gave us a bottle of champagne for our trouble, and also a late check out. That’s how you handle something going wrong for your guest! There is a roof top deck with good views. I would definitely stay there again!