I almost don't want to write this review, because we had such a wonderful time that we want to keep this gem to ourselves!
But the trip was too amazing to not give it a 5-star review.
We hadn't even left the farmhouse yet, and we were already making plans to come back to it. We're a family of five (kids are 9, 6, and 3), and this vacation was absolutely perfect. It was wonderful to start each day with a cup of coffee out on the porch, breathing in the crisp autumn air, listening to the sounds of nature, and looking out at the beautiful foliage that completely surrounded us. We walked to the farm up the hill, where they were extremely friendly. The kids got to pet their horse, and they let us pick whatever we wanted from was left of the pumpkins (which meant I got to pack 4 shopping bags full of mini-pumpkins in the car!). The hiking trails were beautiful, and were a welcome escape from the trails we hike in NJ that are usually crowded with other hikers. Definitely be sure to check out Rustic Ridge Winery. The pizza from the pizza truck was delicious, and it was so nice to sit outside with a tasting flight of beers and enjoy the scenery. We went to Cooperstown on our last day, but stopped at Fly Creek Cider Mill on the way (definitely get the doughnuts if you stop!). It was an easy drive to Cooperstown, and we'll probably spend more time there next time we come up.
If you're looking for a scenic getaway, you'd be hard pressed to find anything better.