Ratings based on 37 Guest Reviews
Hear it directly from our travellers
4.8 Room cleanliness
TRAVELOCITY GUEST REVIEWS
Hear it directly from our travellers
by A traveller
Golf weekend
Posted Oct. 14, 2024 on HomeAwaySecond time we have stayed at this property. Plenty of room and beds for all of us with a number of rooms for us to all congregate in. Quiet secluded area but only minutes to downtown Cooperstown.
by A traveller
Seasoned traveler
Posted Sep. 30, 2024 on HomeAwayOverall a great stay. Good location. Owner/manager was quick to get back to us and very communicative. A couple negatives, There is no soap in any of the showers which was annoying. Also no shampoo/conditioner. I brought shampoo but no one else did. No one brought soap or body wash expecting tit to be there.
The kitchen is stocked well but no oils to cook with which I realize is not required but in other houses we’ve stayed in always there. Also there was no dish soap which should be required.
The house is large and can accommodate a large party which is great.
Comment from Hotel Management
Nov. 5, 2024 by VrboOwner, Hotel Management
Robin, I'm glad you had a "great stay, thought the location was good, the kitchen was stocked, and that the house was large and could accommodate a large party." I'm sad I never knew/heard that my cleaners didn't put out the soap. If I would have known; I would have brought them over immediately. My crew and I apologize about the soap not being put out! -- We do not provide oils in the kitchen for a variety of reasons. If previous renters leave their oils, then we leave them behind. -- We enjoyed having you stay with us. We hope to see you again for another week:o))
by A traveller from Oak Hill, VA
Close to CDP
Posted Aug. 17, 2024 on HomeAwayDan was a wonderful host. We had an issue with one of the A/C units and he came out within the hour to check on it and even brought a replacement unit in case he couldn't fix the one that was there.
The house has 3 bathrooms and was perfect for 3 families to share; each bathroom has nearby bedrooms/space. The 3 twin bed room is great for older siblings as there is a "den" area in the room and gives them a separate space to hang out.
We really enjoyed our time in Cooperstown!
by A traveller
Fantasy Baseball Draft/Hall of Fame
Posted Mar. 25, 2024 on HomeAwayOur group of 10 held our yearly fantasy baseball draft in conjunction with a hall of fame visit for a complete baseball weekend. We loved the property and the host Dan was extremely helpful. Wish we weren't digging ourselves out of 6 inches of snow on the morning we left, but you can't stop Mother Nature. Thank you Dan for a wonderful experience.
by A traveller
Hall of Fame Weekend
Posted Nov. 3, 2023 on HomeAwayThis rustic setting was a perfect base for three couples to enjoy autumn leaves, the quaint village of Cooperstown and the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Multiple bedrooms and bathrooms gave everyone privacy; the kitchen is well equipped for making meals; and the first floor bedroom and bath made this home accessible for my semi-ambulatory wife. Hosts were responsive to inquiries. Only wish the weather was a bit better, and the fish in the pond were easier to catch.
by A traveller
Celebration of Life
Posted Oct. 16, 2023 on HomeAwayWe were up to bury our Mother's Ashes nearby. The property more than accomodated the 9 of us. It was a beautiful property. Dan was quick to reply to questions! We would happily return!
by A traveller
Fantastic property
Posted Oct. 2, 2023 on HomeAwayWe loved our stay at Cornish Hill. We had 4 baseball families join us during our sons Cooperstown Tournament and staying at this house was the cherry on-top of our experience. Highly recommended!!
by A traveller
Weekend family reunion
Posted Sep. 10, 2023 on HomeAwayReally enjoyed our stay. Excellent layout for our group of 12. Used the gas grill for lunch, the gas fire pit for evening conversation. Plenty of parking and well lit drive.
by A traveller
Quick weekend getaway
Posted Apr. 27, 2023 on HomeAwaySpent a weekend exploring the area with family for my son’s 7th birthday. Lovely home and property- the kids had a blast fishing and running around the property! The homeowners couldn’t have been kinder or more accommodating. Appreciated the well stocked home! Super close to Cooperstown village too!
by A traveller from Wilbraham, MA
Great house for a family holiday gathering!
Posted Jan. 2, 2023 on HomeAwayHouse was clean and well maintained with a historic feel. Well-stocked kitchen, comfortable heat, and very helpful owners. Very close to downtown Cooperstown. We visited over New Year’s weekend and the house had perfect little bits of holiday decor which was a thoughtful touch. The only minor downside was a little bit of a muddy driveway, due to gravel being a little worn and getting a lot of rain the first couple days of our stay. We would definitely stay again and recommend for families. Was also easy for my elderly mother to get in and out of house with one small step to get in and out and a perfect bedroom and bath on the first floor for her.
