Ratings based on 9 Guest Reviews
Hear it directly from our travellers
5.0 Room cleanliness
TRAVELOCITY GUEST REVIEWS
Hear it directly from our travellers
by A traveller
Best Week-Long Trip Our Family Has Had
Posted Jul. 17, 2024 on HomeAwayHalfway through the week, my wife turned to me and commented that this was the best week-long trip we had taken as a family. The house, its proximity to South Sandy Beach, the plane ride, and, of course The Bakery all added up to an amazing time on an exceptional island experience. Having visited 15+ islands in Maine now, we've really found our Goldilocks island.
This island isn't for everyone. If you're looking for amenities, places to eat, go out at night, or really do anything like that, you're in the wrong place. This is the island for you if you want to spend quality time with your family or friends free of technology, distractions, or any pretenses.
This is also a place where you need to be flexible. When it came time to leave, the flights were grounded due to fog for three days, and the daily boat to the mainland was full, so we had to extend our time on the island, which actually turned out to be a major bonus.
Thanks again for hosting us! We'll be back for sure.
by A traveller from Atkinson, US
Great place for a quiet stay on the island
Posted Jun. 27, 2024 on HomeAwayWe enjoyed our stay and hope to visit again.
by A traveller
A Welcome Return After 15 Years
Posted Aug. 27, 2021 on HomeAwayDavid made my return to this special corner of Maine damn-near perfect. For months, I had promised my partner and our friends that Matinicus was "a one-of-a-kind place." They took me at my word. Thanks to David and his magical property - the week's vacation lived up to the hype.
Matinicus is no easy place to get to. David was ready and willing to help make sure that we got there in one piece, and that when we arrived the house was in pristine condition.
The Free Library adds a great touch to this getaway, as you can walk down the street and rent an assortment of movies after yet another gorgeous day at the beach.
Thanks again for the great vacation - I felt like I was a kid again!
-Sam
by A traveller from Portland, ME
Wonderful Week on Matinicus
Posted Jul. 7, 2021 on HomeAwayWe had such a wonderful stay on Matinicus! Dave is a joy to work with and was extremely communicative, going out of his way to make sure that we had an amazing time. The house is gorgeous and even bigger than expected, and it has absolutely every amenity you could hope for and more! I will definitely be trying to return, everything about the trip was perfection.
by A traveller
Relaxing Getaway
Posted Jul. 2, 2021 on HomeAwayIdeally located near the big attractions in town (library, playground, post office) and the open spaces on the island's south end (Matinicus Trail, South Sandy Beach), this home felt connected to this unique community but private and restful. Otherwise as others have described. Even when the wind was blowing 25-30 mph, the house felt nearly airtight. A unique property. We hope we can be lucky enough to get back. Also, Dave was a great and thoughtful host, who navigated a fast turnaround for us between the previous tenants and our visit. Can't thank him enough for the great and memorable stay.
by A traveller
Accommodations were very nice and clean. We had a great time.
Posted Jun. 15, 2021 on HomeAwayProperty was larger than expected and nicer than expected. Great Ocean views as well!
by A traveller
Idyllic Retreat
Posted Aug. 16, 2020 on HomeAwayDave was a wonderful host, communications were quick and friendly. Location is private, quiet, close to the beach, and well stocked with everything we needed. Matinicus is far off the beaten path, but well worth the trip!
by A traveller
Truly the most spectacular vacation we have ever had!
Posted Aug. 6, 2020 on HomeAwayThis was our first trip to Matinicus Island and we feel so lucky to have stumbled upon Dave’s house! The location at the south end of the island put us in short walking distance of the most stunning black sand beach (the walk there through gorgeous wild fields of sea grasses and wildflowers was great too).
The house itself is absolutely wonderful- brand new, filled with light, fresh air, and great views. It feels like it was professionally decorated and was truly the most relaxing space we have ever rented. The deck outside spans the entire front of the house and can be accessed by three different rooms. It was the ideal spot to take in the perfectly framed view of Criehaven Island while sorting the day’s sea glass (SO MUCH seaglass!) and sand dollars (which my city kids have never seen before), prepare delicious lobster brought to us by a local neighbor, or watch for shooting stars and marveling at the Milky Way.
Last, but not least, Dave, our host, as well as every single neighbor we met, made up the most generous, friendly, and helpful group of people we have ever encountered in our travels. I don’t think I have ever been on a two week vacation before and left feeling like I had made friends who I look forward to seeing again.
All in all, such a special place for a family looking to breathe, recharge, and just BE.
by A traveller
Matinicus
Posted Jul. 28, 2019 on HomeAwayMatinicus is such a beautiful quiet island. We loved our stay. Location was a quick bike ride to south beach. House was clean and big. We slept in the new addition. Daily trips to Eva’s bakery were a must. Found lots of rare colors of sea glass. We swam daily (with wet suits). Beach was almost always deserted. Campfire on the beach (below high water mark) and enjoyed the super dark skies. Took a side trip to Matinicus Rock aboard George’s boat and saw puffins, razorbills, guillemot, and common murre. All around a successful trip. Bikes are a must.
